By Nate Moser
The Carolina Hurricanes announced that President and General Manager Don Waddell resigned from his position with the team. The search is on from the organization to find the right replacement, but for now, Eric Tulsky has been named the interim general manager. As for Waddell, there is already talk that he may join the Columbus Blue Jackets. Would he become the next President of Hockey Operations and oversee the general manager? It seems to be the case, but that will be made clear once the Blue Jackets make the announcement official. What is known, however, is that Waddell brings a lot to the table in experience. He will make a significant impact to the Blue Jackets franchise in whatever his duties are.
Waddell made a name for himself when he became the first general manager in franchise history for the Atlanta Thrashers. The NHL expanded to the city of Atlanta for the second time in the late 1990s after their original team, the Atlanta Flames, relocated to Calgary. Waddell had just come off winning a Stanley Cup with the 1997-98 Detroit Red Wings as assistant general manager. He spent a long time in his first GM role with the Thrashers. He was brought in as first GM for the organization, and lasted there until he was promoted to president after the 2009-10 season was over. Waddell never left the organization until the very end when the Thrashers were going to be moved to Winnipeg and be renamed the Jets.
It is not just the fact that Waddell was around a long time that makes him a solid hockey executive. In this instance, quantity of years being in a role does not really matter if there isn’t good enough quality to show for it. Waddell brought quality to the Thrashers. Russian superstar Ilya Kovalchuk debuted and broke out in the NHL as a player for Atlanta. Before Dany Heatley became a two-time 50 goal scorer for the Ottawa Senators, where did he play and who brought him there? Atlanta and Waddell. Other significant Thrashers who Waddell was responsible for bringing in include Marc Savard, Marian Hossa, Kari Lehtonen, Slava Kozlov, and Peter Bondra among others. Based on all of the talent brought in, it should have been able to work. Despite the star power, Waddell’s Thrasher teams always managed to underachieve. In fact, this Atlanta team only made the playoffs once, which was back during the 2006-07 season. The organization lasted a little over a decade, but there was never a second postseason run.
Things were not perfect under Waddell of course. The playoff drought stat is already a rough start, but he was also involved in selecting one of the biggest draft busts in league history. That title “Biggest Bust” is reserved for a select few. There’s Alexandre Daigle, Nail Yakupov, and in the 1999 NHL Entry Draft, there was Patrik Stefan. Waddell chose Stefan with the first overall pick when other names were on the board. The Sedin Brothers did want to play in the NHL together so that was a unique situation, but neither of those were picked first overall. Tim Connolly was there, who instead went to the New York Islanders at fifth overall. Other players who could have been Thrashers in the 1999 Draft over Stefan: Martin Havlat, Mike Commodore, Jordan Leopold, Mike Comrie, Chris Kelly, Ryan Malone, Ryan Miller, Henrik Zetterberg, and Radim Vrbata. Meanwhile, Stefan put up the following numbers while being a Thrasher:
- 1999-00: five goals and 20 assists for 25 points in 72 games
- 2000-01: 10 goals and 21 assists for 31 points in 66 games
- 2001-02: seven goals and 16 assists for 23 points in 59 games
- 2002-03: 13 goals and 21 assists for 34 points in 71 games
- 2003-04: 14 goals and 26 assists for 40 points in 82 games
- 2005-06: 10 goals and 14 assists for 24 points in 64 games
Stefan later finished up his career after playing the 2006-07 NHL season with the Dallas Stars, where he was remembered for the infamous empty net goal miss against the Edmonton Oilers.
Where Waddell missed on Stefan, he made up for with selecting Ilya Kovalchuk first overall in the 2001 NHL Draft. Kovalchuk finished his Thrashers career as the franchise leader in goals (328), assists (287), and points (615). However, Waddell does deserve his share of criticism for the fact that despite having an insanely talented player like Kovalchuk, despite his best efforts, the team only made the playoffs once.
Where things get positive for Waddell as a general manager again is when he joined the Hurricanes back in 2018. He immediately had a responsibility to select a crucial player to the team, which had the second overall pick in the 2018 NHL Draft. He chose Andrei Svechnikov, who has become a core member for Carolina with his best stats still to come as he continues to grow as a young player. Waddell is also responsible for drafting Seth Jarvis, Jack Drury, and Pyotr Kochetkov. He played a role in bringing in talents from other NHL squads like Freddy Andersen, Jesperi Kotkaniemi, Brent Burns, Jake Guentzel, and Dmitry Orlov among others. Not only did this lead to playoff berths, but the team also made the second round four straight seasons in a row. They even made the Eastern Conference Final back in 2022-23 but were swept by their former Southeast Division rival Florida Panthers.
Now, Waddell has the potential opportunity to make a difference for Columbus. It does not appear be as a general manager, but his input will help shape the future of the Blue Jackets no matter as a GM, advisor, or other role. Columbus has many skilled talents on their roster. There’s Johnny Gaudreau, Patrik Laine, recently-drafted forward Adam Fantilli, captain Boone Jenner, Zach Werenski, Damon Severson, and Ivan Provorov. Former Jackets GM Jarmo Kekalainen did the best he could while in his position, but the results were not enough to keep him around longer. Also, he had been in the organization for a long time, and it was time for a new direction. Waddell can now help tweak things in his image, and try to get the Blue Jackets to become one of the most dangerous rosters in the NHL. Once again, the actual hiring of Waddell to Columbus is not official as of yet, so what he is doing for the team is not yet known. There is a possible partnership though between both sides, and time will tell if it is a winning combination.