BY MIKE RIFKIN
On Sunday the Dolphins squandered a 17 point lead against the lowly Carolina Panthers and lost 27-24. At 1-4 the Dolphins most likely will miss the playoffs for a second consecutive season, and that leaves a fork in the road for the organization. Chris Grier and the front office have two choices : choice one would be to keep things status quo and just say this is a bad year. Choice two : tear parts of this team down and stockpile draft picks.
I would choose choice two and here’s why: As long as Josh Allen is in the AFC East, the Dolphins aren’t beating the Bills currently constructed, that’s been proven time and time again. The other reason is in the Mike Mcdaniel/Tua Tagovailoa era the Dolphins struggle with good football teams, especially late in the season. If you want to eventually hoist the Lombardi you have to beat good teams. So how would I fix the Dolphins if I was Chris Grier? Let’s do it
The first key date is November fourth, that’s the trade deadline in the NFL. Prior to his injury it was safe to assume Tyreek Hill was going to be traded, his name had already surfaced in trade rumors. Other names I would include would be Edges Bradley Chubb and Jaelan Phillips. Now, if it were up to me I wouldn’t move Phillips, despite a few injury plagued seasons there is still a lot of upside in my opinion. Matt Judon, who is on a one year deal could also be expendable. Two guys I wouldn’t move but you might hear about are Linebacker Jordyn Brooks and Safety Minkah Fitzpatrick, both of whom are under contract through next season, and one thing this team needs is leadership.
The ultimate decisions are going to come this offseason. Let’s start with Mike McDaniel. Unless this team turns it around and shows some fight McDaniel will be gone at the end of the year. Is it warranted, that’s debatable but he really hasn’t grown in game and his offense isn’t fooling anyone at the moment. Now is that McDaniel or limitations on Tua? That’s got to be something to think about. Speaking of Tua, he’s going to make 39 million next season. He hasn’t played like the franchise Quarterback some think of him as. Let’s be honest he is not in the class of Allen, Mahomes, Lamar, and Burrow. Part of that might be injuries and part of that is he is not a big guy. The Dolphins created a speed offense with his accurate arm and now there has been no adjustment. Tua has to be on the team next year because nobody is taking on the contract, but that shouldn’t stop the team from potentially drafting a Quarterback.
Not sure what names will be out there this offseason, and when the time comes I’ll break it down. But Sunday’s loss for the Dolphins means that there needs to be changes made, because this roster isn’t it and this team hasn’t won a playoff game in 25 years, that needs to change. But after Sunday the 2025 season is done.